CN Mobile Logo

Search form


Eight-Year NSABP Data Confirm Radiation Benefits in DCIS

Eight-Year NSABP Data Confirm Radiation Benefits in DCIS

PARIS--Detection rates of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) have soared thanks to mammography but, to date, only one randomized trial has attempted to quell the resulting therapeutic turmoil. Now, eight-year follow-up results from that NSABP trial indicate that the advantages of breast irradiation following local excision continue to be maintained over the long term. "All patients benefit from radiation," Bernard Fisher, MD, scientific director of the NSABP, said at the Seventh International Congress on Anti-Cancer Treatment (ICACT). "The most optimal prevention of second ipsilateral breast tumors is free specimen margins and post-lumpectomy radiation."

Dr. Fisher pointed out that second tumors in the ipsilateral breast developed in 27% of women with DCIS who had been treated with lumpectomy alone and that nearly half of these tumors were invasive. In contrast, only 12% of women treated with postsurgical breast irradiation developed second tumors, roughly a third of which were invasive.

"The important question is whether you get an invasive cancer from DCIS, and these data show how well radiation works in controlling the development of ipsilateral invasive breast tumors," he said. The eight-year rates of local-regional disease, distant disease, and deaths were equally small in both NSABP treatment arms, however.

In an effort to pinpoint those subgroups of patients that would most benefit from radiation, the NSABP investigators examined the value of pathologic characteristics in predicting the development of a second ipsilateral breast tumor. Multivariate analysis revealed that comedo necrosis and margin involvement were the only independent prognostic factors, Dr. Fisher said.

Nevertheless, he emphasized, radiation was effective irrespective of nuclear grade, histologic type, tumor size, the presence or absence of comedo necrosis, and margin involvement.

Best and Worst Scenarios

"Even in the worst scenario, with involved margins and marked comedo necrosis, radiation reduces the risk of ipsilateral breast tumors to a very low level," he said. "And if you take the best scenario, with free margins and absent-to-slight comedo necrosis, radiation still has some effect in improving the situation."

Thus, Dr. Fisher maintains that "despite its heterogeneity, DCIS warrants management by local excision and radiation regardless of the presence or absence of favorable tumor characteristics."

He warned against the use of prognostic models in clinical decision making, reminding the audience that models to predict which DCIS patients can safely forego radiation, such as the Van Nuys index, have never been validated with prospective clinical trials.

In a newly completed NSABP trial, Dr. Fisher said, women with more extensive DCIS have been treated with lumpectomy and breast irradiation, stratified by age, and then randomized to tamoxifen (Nolvadex) or placebo.

Loading comments...

By clicking Accept, you agree to become a member of the UBM Medica Community.