SALT LAKE CITYA single fraction of 8 Gy of radiation
therapy is as efficacious as 30 Gy delivered in 10 fractions for palliation of
painful bone metastases and causes less acute toxicity, reported William F.
Hartsell, MD, at the 45th Annual Meeting of the American Society for
Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology (plenary session, abstract 1).
In the phase III randomized trial (RTOG 9714), two thirds of
patients in both groups had partial or complete relief of their pain at 3
months; the only tradeoff of the single-fraction strategy was a somewhat higher
rate of retreatment, said Dr. Hartsell, medical director of radiation oncology,
Advocate Lutheran General Hospital, Park Ridge, Illinois.
Patients enrolled in the trial had breast or prostate
cancer; moderate-to-severe self-reported pain (a worst score on the Brief Pain
Index of 5 or higher); radiographic evidence of metastases at painful sites;
stable systemic therapy in the prior month; and a life expectancy of greater
than 3 months. None had received prior palliative radiation therapy at painful
sites or had cord compression, radicular symptoms, or pathologic fractures.
"Patients were entered onto this study from 160-plus
institutions around the United States and Canada, so this is truly a
collaborative effort throughout North America," Dr. Hartsell remarked.
Outcomes were compared for 454 patients treated with 8 Gy in
a single fraction and 443 patients treated with 30 Gy in 10 fractions. Patients
in the two groups were similar with respect to age (mean, 65 years), sex (1:1),
race (about 75% white and 15% black), and functional status (Karnofsky
performance status score of 80 or lower in about 75%).
The groups were also well balanced with respect to the
distribution of four prespecified stratification variables: number of painful
sites (solitary vs multiple); skeletal location of the site(s) (weight-bearing
vs non-weight-bearing); bisphosphonate use (yes vs no); and initial worst pain
score (5 to 6 vs 7 to 10).
Overall, about half of patients had solitary painful sites
and sites located in weight-bearing bones; nearly three fourths had worst pain
scores of 7 to 10, and about one fourth were taking bisphosphonates.
At 3 months, the majority of patients in both the
single-fraction (65%) and multifraction group (66%) had either a partial
response (a 2-point improvement in worst pain score) or a complete response (a
score of 0 on at least two consecutive assessments), Dr. Hartsell said.
Absolute scores indicated that half of patients in both groups had no or only
mild pain at that time. In addition, when patients were stratified according to
the four prespecified variables, rates of complete pain relief did not differ
between groups. One third of patients in each group were not taking narcotics,
Patients in the single-fraction and multifraction groups had
a similar median survival time (9.1 and 9.5 months, respectively) and similar
1-year survival rates (41% vs 42%), Dr. Hartsell said.
The rate of acute toxicity was significantly lower among
patients in the single-fraction group than among those in the multifraction
group; the rate of late toxicity was similar. Pathologic fractures within or
adjacent to the treatment field occurred with equal frequency in the two
Patients in the single-fraction group were significantly
more likely than those in the multifraction group to need in-field retreatment
by 3 months (10% vs 4%). "This 2:1 incidence of retreatment was maintained
all the way through the 36 months of follow-up," he noted.
Dr. Hartsell pointed out that the patients in the study had
relatively advanced disease. "These are not patients who just had
metastatic disease diagnosed," he said, adding that better results might
be achievable with earlier delivery of radiation therapy. He said that the team
is still evaluating the health utilities and cost analysis, and that will help
determine whether 8 Gy in a single fraction is the optimum treatment.
"My personal bias is that we have a treatment that is very effective
and is much more convenient for the patient. A single dose of 8 Gy will provide
identical pain relief with the caveat that a few patients will need additional
treatment," Dr. Hartsell said. "If you were at a medical oncology
meeting and a drug was presented that gave pain relief whether you gave it in 1
cycle or 10 cycles, and the only difference was that in the group that got 1
cycle, a small proportion had to get a second treatment, what would your