ROCKVILLE, Maryland-
After priority review, the US Food
and Drug Administration (FDA) has
approved Tarceva tablets (erlotinib,
OSI Pharmaceuticals) as a singleagent
treatment for patients with locally
advanced or metastatic non-
small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC)
whose disease has continued to
progress despite other therapies, including
at least one prior chemotherapy
regimen. The FDA granted
marketing approval on the basis of
increased survival findings in the
Tarceva-treated arm of a phase III
trial in patients who had received
second- or third-line therapy for advanced
NSCLC.
"FDA believes it is crucial for cancer
patients to have many safe and
effective treatment options in their
battle against this disease" said
Lester M. Crawford, MD, Acting
FDA Commissioner. "With the approval
of Tarceva, thousands of patients
with lung cancer will not only
have access to another treatment
option, but one that extends life."
Tarceva, which is distributed by
Genentech, is an epidermal growth
factor receptor (EGFR) inhibitor;
while it is known to block the tyrosine
kinase associated with EGFR,
the mechanism of action by which it
exerts its clinical benefit is not completely
understood. It is the first of
its class to demonstrate a survival
advantage for advanced NSCLC in a
phase III trial. However, two large,
randomized studies of Tarceva given
concurrently with doublet platinum-
based chemotherapy (carboplatin
[Paraplatin] and paclitaxel(Drug information on paclitaxel) or gemcitabine(Drug information on gemcitabine) [Gemzar] and cisplatin(Drug information on cisplatin))
to patients with previously untreated
advanced NSCLC failed to show
clinical benefit, and the drug is not
recommended for such use.
The pivotal clinical study on
which the FDA based its approval
decision for Tarceva was conducted
by the National Cancer Institute of
Canada Clinical Trials Group, based
at Queen's University, Kingston,
Ontario, Canada, in collaboration
with OSI Pharmaceuticals. It involved
731 patients with locally advanced
or metastatic NSCLC in a
randomized, double-blind, placebocontrolled
trial conducted in 17
countries. Patients were randomized
2:1 to Tarceva 150 mg or to placebo,
given orally once daily until disease
progression or unacceptable toxicity
occurred.
Study Results
The primary endpoint and all secondary
endpoints of the trial were
met. Survival, progression-free survival,
and tumor response all proved
to be significant in favor of Tarceva
(P = < .001). Median survival time,
evaluated in an intent-to-treat population,
was 6.7 months for Tarceva
vs 4.7 months for placebo. Median
progression-free survival time was
9.9 weeks vs 7.9 weeks, respectively,
and the Tarceva-treated patients had
a tumor response rate of 8.9%, vs
0.9% for placebo. One-year survival
was 31.2% in the treatment group
vs 21.5% for the control patients,
and median duration of response
was 34.3 weeks vs 15.9 weeks, respectively.
Subgroup Analyses
A series of patient subsets of were
examined in exploratory univariate
analyses. Tarceva's survival effect was
similar across most subsets, although
in two subsets, a larger survival effect
was observed (EGFR-positive patients
and patients who never smoked).
Among the 238 patients with a
known EGFR status, the 78 EGFRpositive
Tarceva patients had a better
survival rate than the 49 EGFR-posi-
tive placebo patients (hazard ratio
[HR] = 0.65). Tarceva did not appear
to affect survival in the EGFR-negative
subgroup (HR = 1.01). A survival
benefit due to Tarceva in the EGFRnegative
subgroup cannot be excluded,
however, because the confidence
intervals for the EGFR-positive, -negative,
and unmeasured subgroups are
wide and overlap (see Table 1).
Nonsmokers in the study who
were EGFR-positive had a large
Tarceva survival benefit (HR = 0.27).
Twenty percent (146) of the study
participants had never smoked.
Tumor responses were observed in
all EGFR subgroups.
The most common grade 3-4 adverse
events in the Tarceva-treated
patients were rash (9%) and diarrhea
(6%).
