Proton beam therapy: ‘What is all the fuss?’

By Marc A. Melser, MD
Port Charlotte, Florida

| June 1, 2008

I would like to share my comments on proton beam radiation and the purported need for randomized trials before it is widely accepted for use in prostate cancer. [See ONI April 2008, page 1, and May 2008, page 44.]

I am a urologist in southwest Florida. As I discussed with one of our radiation oncologists (we use 21st Century Oncology), there are no trials comparing proton and standard radiation, eg, IMRT. If such a trial were conducted, I suspect, at best, the cancer control rates would be equivalent, and the side effect profiles would also be similar. So what is all the fuss?

I liken the argument to that of robotic vs standard open radical prostatectomy. While the robotic procedure is a terrific operation, I am unaware of a study showing superiority with regards to cancer control, continence, and potency—the three main outcomes of all prostate cancer Marc A. Melser, MD treatments. So why are so many patients flocking to the hospitals with the robot? America is enthralled with high tech. Proton beam therapy will attract the individuals who have the need to be treated with the supposed latest and greatest technology, data or no data. And let us not forget the power of marketing.

The initial start up costs for a proton therapy center are prohibitive. That $100 million could be spent on other areas of healthcare. The nation needs a small number of proton units to treat the uncommon tumors for which a difference can be made. However, for prostate cancer, if I were an insurer, I would pay the IMRT rate for proton therapy. I would demand head-to-head trials. If you want the extra reimbursement, show superior results. Sadly, this scenario is unlikely.

Marc A. Melser, MD
Port Charlotte, Florida

TOPIC INDEX

Cancer Types
Breast Breast (HER2+) Breast (Triple-Negative) CML Colorectal Gastrointestinal GIST Genitourinary Gynecologic Head & Neck	Hematology Kidney (Renal Cell) Leukemia Lung Lymphoma Melanoma Multiple Myeloma Ovarian Prostate Sarcoma
Supportive Care	More Topics
Bone Metastases End-of-Life Care Palliative Care	Ethics in Oncology Practice Management Practice & Policy

All Topics

FROM PHYSICIANS PRACTICE

Primary Care Can't Thrive Without Nurse Practitioners
Courtney H. Lyder, ND, May 17, 2013
With a projected shortfall of primary-care physicians, it's time for alternate solutions to patient care. Nurse practitioners are one logical remedy.

VWhat Physicians Can Learn from the Allscripts EHR Lawsuit
Marisa Torrieri, May 16, 2013
Lawsuit prompts question: What should physicians do to ensure they end up with a great EHR instead of buyer’s remorse?

Eight Ways ICD-9 Will Still Matter to Medical Practices
Brenda Edwards, CPC, May 15, 2013
What should your medical practice do with your ICD-9-CM book after October 1, 2014? Keep it.

Seven Ways Technology Can Speed Up Patient Collections
Cheyenne Brinson, May 15, 2013
Failing to adopt widely available billing and collections technology can cost medical practices big. Here's how to do it right.

Four Reasons Private Medical Practice is Becoming Extinct
Carol Stryker, May 15, 2013
It’s becoming increasingly difficult for private medical practices to thrive. Here’s what’s driving the trend toward consolidation.

Proton beam therapy: ‘What is all the fuss?’

Join the Conversation