News
Clinical Topics
Integrative Care
Global Bulletin
All News
Approval Alert
Media
2 Minute Drill
Around the Practice
Between the Lines
Clinical Consult
Expert Interviews
Face Off
Medical World News
Morning Rounds
OncView
Podcasts
Readout 360
Satellite Sessions
Sponsored Media
Training Academy
Year in Review
Conferences
Publications
All Journals
For Authors
Tumor Board
Events
Frontline Forum
CME/CE
Resources
Contemporary Concepts
Awareness Month
Interactive Tools
Nurse Practitioners/Physician's Assistants
Partners
Sponsored
Subscribe
Print Subscription
eNewsletter

logo
Spotlight
Around the Practice
Between the Lines
Contemporary Concepts
Journal
OncView
Podcasts
Readout 360
2022 ASCO Genitourinary Cancers Symposium Urothelial Cancer Updates
CancerNetwork® Inaugural Face-Off
Contemporary Concepts in Hematologic Oncology
Insights from Experts at Mayo Clinic on Translating Evidence to Clinical Practice
Optimizing Outcomes in Patients with HER2+ Metastatic Breast Cancer
Clinical
Acute Myeloid Leukemia
Brain Cancer
Breast Cancer
Gastrointestinal Cancer
Genitourinary Cancer
Gynecologic Cancer
Hematology
Leukemia
Lung Cancer
Lymphoma
Pediatric Cancers
Skin Cancer
Clinical Topics
Integrative Care
Global Bulletin
All News
Approval Alert
2 Minute Drill
Around the Practice
Between the Lines
Clinical Consult
Expert Interviews
Face Off
Medical World News
Morning Rounds
OncView
Podcasts
Readout 360
Satellite Sessions
Sponsored Media
Training Academy
Year in Review
Conferences
All Journals
For Authors
Tumor Board
Frontline Forum
CME/CE
Contemporary Concepts
Awareness Month
Interactive Tools
Nurse Practitioners/Physician's Assistants
Partners
Sponsored
Print Subscription
eNewsletter
Advertisement
Breast Cancer
| Kidney Cancer
| Leukemia
| Lymphoma
| Multiple Myeloma
| Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC)
| Small Cell Lung Cancer (SCLC)
| Adverse Effects
| Biomarkers
| Bladder Cancer
| Brain Cancer
| Cervical Cancer
| Colorectal Cancer
| Endometrial Cancer
| Esophageal Cancer
| Gastrointestinal Cancer
| Genitourinary Cancers
| Gynecologic Cancers
| Head & Neck Cancer
| Hematology
| Hormone-related Cancers
| Immunotherapy
| Infection
| Liver Cancer
| Lung Cancer
| Mesothelioma
| Neuroendocrine Tumors
| Oncology
| Ovarian Cancer
| Ovarian Cancer Clincal Consult
| Pancreatic Cancer
| Pediatric Cancers
| Prostate Cancer
| Radiation Oncology
| Sarcoma
| Screening
| Skin Cancer & Melanoma
| Surgery
| Thoracic Malignancies
| Thyroid Cancer
View All >>
  • Adverse Effects
  • Biomarkers
  • Bladder Cancer
  • Brain Cancer
  • Breast Cancer
  • Cervical Cancer
  • Colorectal Cancer
  • Endometrial Cancer
  • Esophageal Cancer
  • Gastrointestinal Cancer
  • Genitourinary Cancers
  • Gynecologic Cancers
  • Head & Neck Cancer
  • Hematology
  • Hormone-related Cancers
  • Immunotherapy
  • Infection
  • Kidney Cancer
  • Leukemia
  • Liver Cancer
  • Lung Cancer
  • Lymphoma
  • Mesothelioma
  • Multiple Myeloma
  • Neuroendocrine Tumors
  • Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC)
  • Oncology
  • Ovarian Cancer
  • Ovarian Cancer Clincal Consult
  • Pancreatic Cancer
  • Pediatric Cancers
  • Prostate Cancer
  • Radiation Oncology
  • Sarcoma
  • Screening
  • Skin Cancer & Melanoma
  • Small Cell Lung Cancer (SCLC)
  • Surgery
  • Thoracic Malignancies
  • Thyroid Cancer

SPOTLIGHT -

Around the Practice
| Between the Lines
| Contemporary Concepts
| Journal
| OncView
| Podcasts
| Readout 360
| 2022 ASCO Genitourinary Cancers Symposium Urothelial Cancer Updates
| CancerNetwork® Inaugural Face-Off
| Contemporary Concepts in Hematologic Oncology
| Insights from Experts at Mayo Clinic on Translating Evidence to Clinical Practice
| Optimizing Outcomes in Patients with HER2+ Metastatic Breast Cancer

GAR Helps Counter Legal Pitfalls of Cancer Screening, Diagnosis

June 1, 1996
Publication
Article
Oncology NEWS InternationalOncology NEWS International Vol 5 No 6
Volume 5
Issue 6

WASHINGTON--Put GAR in your patients' records. It can prove extremely useful should you find yourself being sued for medical malpractice, Marvin A. Dewar, MD, JD, said at the National Conference on Prevention and Early Detection, sponsored by the American Cancer Society.

WASHINGTON--Put GAR in your patients' records. It can prove extremelyuseful should you find yourself being sued for medical malpractice,Marvin A. Dewar, MD, JD, said at the National Conference on Preventionand Early Detection, sponsored by the American Cancer Society.

GAR is an acronym for "general information, alternatives,risks"--three key points every physicians needs to discusswith patients before cancer screening or diagnosis,

Dr. Dewar, director, Family Practice Residency Program, the Universityof Florida College of Medicine, Gainesville, said that malpracticecases alleging that a physician delayed diagnosis or failed todiagnose a cancer continue to increase.

In a 1991 Florida study, Dr. Dewar and his colleagues found thatin cases involving primary care physicians, failure to diagnosecancer was the most common allegation, representing 16% of allpaid claims, at an average cost of $160,352. Failure to diagnosebreast cancer ranked first, followed by lung, prostate, and coloncancer.

One element in defending against such lawsuits is having and documentinga good informed consent process. And thus, he recommends rememberingGAR.

"Informed consent is a conversation that you as providershave with patients," Dr. Dewar said. "It is the understanding,the meeting of the minds between the patient and the provider.The documentation of the informed consent is not informed consent,but it is important from the legal protection standpoint."

He urged that physicians give each patient general information,explain the alternatives, describe the risks, and note this inthe patient's record.

"A plastic surgeon or a breast surgeon will dictate voluminousand detailed informed consent," Dr. Dewar said. "Atthe cancer detection level, you and I often don't have time todo that. Nonetheless, documentation is important, and I suggestthat you do it."

Impact of Practice Guidelines

Clinical practice guidelines have been the subject of much debateabout whether they increase the risk of malpractice litigationor protect providers and decrease the threat. In fact, such guidelinescan prove to be a mixed blessing. The most helpful practice guidelinesfor physicians, Dr. Dewar commented, are those that are widelyaccepted by the medical community.

In areas where guidelines diverge or conflict, practice recommendations"are not going to carry very much legal weight," hesaid, "because they will be just as confusing to the juryas they are to many providers and patients."

More relevant to malpractice suits are guidelines developed specificallyto address situations that commonly lead to litigation. But mostimportant, practice guidelines "have to be straightforwardand readily interpreted in the litigation setting," Dr. Dewarsaid.

For example, he said, the American Cancer Society's guidelinesfor screening intervals are very simple, clear, and easily understood."They will have more weight in a litigation setting thanwill more lengthy and confusing guidelines."

Defining Medical Negligence

Legally, to succeed in winning compensation in a malpractice suit,a patient must prove medical negligence, and this essentiallyconsists of four points.

First, an obligation must exist that the provider give a certainlevel of care; second, that duty must be breached; third, thatbreach must cause harm to the patient; and fourth, that harm mustinflict legally recognizable damage, such as loss of wages, onthe patient.

Originally, local medical standards served as the criteria fordetermining a physician's standard of care; now physicians facea national standard. "Although the resources may be different,the standard of care that you provide with those resources isgoing to be the same in Wisconsin as it is in Atlanta," Dr.Dewar commented.

However, physicians do have what attorneys call the "respectableminority rule" on their side. This is especially importantin such areas as prostate screening that are marked by scientificcontroversy and varying recommendations and practice guidelines.

"If the care decision that you go by is supported by whatwe call a respectable minority of the medical profession, then,in fact, you have not breached the duty of care," Dr. Dewarsaid. "So in an area where there is tremendous scientificdebate, the clinician is not going to be put on the hook, theoretically,for following one of the viable options."

However, where one practices can make a difference in the criteriafor proving harm, legally referred to as "causation."Most states use "the 51% rule," Dr. Dewar said, whichmeans that "the breach of duty had to be the probable causeof the injury, with a 51% chance that the failure to do something,or the doing of something that shouldn't have been done, led tothe injury."

A minority of states, including Illinois and West Virginia, usea more stringent rule, such as the physician's action resultingin "some loss of chance of a better outcome," and theserules work more to the plaintiff's advantage," he said.

The large majority of medical malpractice suits never stay thefull legal course from accusation to jury verdict, he said. Nationally,73% of medical malpractice cases end in settlement, with another10% dismissed by the courts.

One of physicians' greatest malpractice fears--the awarding ofpunitive damages--is actually quite rare in the health-care setting,Dr. Dewar said, since they require proof of willful and wantonnegligent conduct.

Articles in this issue

Psychosocial Oncology May Benefit From System Reform
Know Your Partners, Know Your Goals in Joint Ventures Between Hospitals and Universities
Managed Care Reform: Wait Until Next Year for House, Senate
Converting Quality of Life Data to 'Q' Scores Allows Comparisons
Shorter Paclitaxel Infusions Add to Neuropathy Risk
Breast Cancer Mortality Rates Down
Pain Scale Resembling Thermometer May Be Easier to Use Than VAS
Immediate Hormone Therapy Improves Prostate Cancer Survival
New Test for Prostate Cancer Risk
Topotecan: Significant Activity in Ovarian Cancer
Prostate Cancer Guideline Classifies Patients By Risk Status
New Monograph Describes Racial/Ethnic Cancer Patterns in the US
Moral Challenges Ahead as Managed Care Marches On
One Doctor Tells His Experience With Hospital Mergers
BRCA2 Gene Mutations Linked to Ovarian Cancer Cases
Related Videos
Experts on CML
Experts on MM
Experts on CML
Experts on MM
KOLs smiling at camera.
KOLs smiling at camera.
Related Content

AVB-001 Receives FDA FTD in Platinum-Resistant Ovarian Cancer

October 3rd 2023

Pipeline Perspectives: Fruquintinib in Metastatic Colorectal Cancer

October 2nd 2023

FDA Approves Pegcetacoplan Injector for Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria

October 3rd 2023

Navigating the Impact of Chemotherapy Shortages on Cancer Care and Finances

September 18th 2023

Alisertib Earns FDA Orphan Drug Designation for Small Cell Lung Cancer

October 2nd 2023

Hypofractionated Vs Standard RT Yields Similar Toxicity in Breast Cancer

October 2nd 2023

AVB-001 Receives FDA FTD in Platinum-Resistant Ovarian Cancer

October 3rd 2023

Pipeline Perspectives: Fruquintinib in Metastatic Colorectal Cancer

October 2nd 2023

FDA Approves Pegcetacoplan Injector for Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria

October 3rd 2023

Navigating the Impact of Chemotherapy Shortages on Cancer Care and Finances

September 18th 2023

Alisertib Earns FDA Orphan Drug Designation for Small Cell Lung Cancer

October 2nd 2023

Hypofractionated Vs Standard RT Yields Similar Toxicity in Breast Cancer

October 2nd 2023

AVB-001 Receives FDA FTD in Platinum-Resistant Ovarian Cancer

October 3rd 2023

Pipeline Perspectives: Fruquintinib in Metastatic Colorectal Cancer

October 2nd 2023

FDA Approves Pegcetacoplan Injector for Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria

October 3rd 2023

Navigating the Impact of Chemotherapy Shortages on Cancer Care and Finances

September 18th 2023

Alisertib Earns FDA Orphan Drug Designation for Small Cell Lung Cancer

October 2nd 2023

Hypofractionated Vs Standard RT Yields Similar Toxicity in Breast Cancer

October 2nd 2023
Related Content
Advertisement

Investigators are assessing AVB-001 as a treatment for those with high-grade serous adenocarcinoma of the ovary, primary peritoneum, or fallopian tube in a phase 1/2 trial.

AVB-001 Receives FDA FTD in Platinum-Resistant Ovarian Cancer

October 3rd 2023
Article

Investigators are assessing AVB-001 as a treatment for those with high-grade serous adenocarcinoma of the ovary, primary peritoneum, or fallopian tube in a phase 1/2 trial.


Arvind N. Dasari, MD, and Cathy Eng, MD, discuss clinical trial data that may support the FDA approval of fruquintinib in metastatic colorectal cancer, and how it may impact the standard of care.

Pipeline Perspectives: Fruquintinib in Metastatic Colorectal Cancer

October 2nd 2023
Podcast

Arvind N. Dasari, MD, and Cathy Eng, MD, discuss clinical trial data that may support the FDA approval of fruquintinib in metastatic colorectal cancer, and how it may impact the standard of care.


Patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria can now self-administer pegcetacoplan subcutaneously following the FDA’s approval of an injector.

FDA Approves Pegcetacoplan Injector for Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria

October 3rd 2023
Article

Patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria can now self-administer pegcetacoplan subcutaneously following the FDA’s approval of an injector.


Pharmaceutical, gynecologic oncology, and physician perspectives shed light on potentially mitigating the ongoing carboplatin and cisplatin shortages’ effects on cancer care in the United States.

Navigating the Impact of Chemotherapy Shortages on Cancer Care and Finances

September 18th 2023
Podcast

Pharmaceutical, gynecologic oncology, and physician perspectives shed light on potentially mitigating the ongoing carboplatin and cisplatin shortages’ effects on cancer care in the United States.


Alisertib will be assessed in patients with small cell lung cancer as part of the phase 2 Study PUMA-ALI-4201.

Alisertib Earns FDA Orphan Drug Designation for Small Cell Lung Cancer

October 2nd 2023
Article

Alisertib will be assessed in patients with small cell lung cancer as part of the phase 2 Study PUMA-ALI-4201.


Data from the FABREC trial support the use of hypofractionated postmastectomy radiotherapy in patients with breast cancer following implant-based reconstruction.

Hypofractionated Vs Standard RT Yields Similar Toxicity in Breast Cancer

October 2nd 2023
Article

Data from the FABREC trial support the use of hypofractionated postmastectomy radiotherapy in patients with breast cancer following implant-based reconstruction.

About
Advertise
CureToday.com
OncLive.com
OncNursingNews.com
TargetedOnc.com
Contact
Terms and Conditions
Privacy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

2 Clarke Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2023 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.