Complete resection of kidney mets ups overall survival

Oncology NEWS InternationalOncology NEWS International Vol 19 No 4
Volume 19
Issue 4

Patients who undergo resection of all metastatic kidney lesions, especially of disease that has spread to the lungs, appear to have outcomes as good as patients who have only a single surgery.

SAN FRANCISCO-Patients who undergo resection of all metastatic kidney lesions, especially of disease that has spread to the lungs, appear to have outcomes as good as patients who have only a single surgery, according to a presentation at the 2010 Genitourinary Cancers Symposium.

Overall, about 31% of 125 patients who underwent complete resection of all metastases were alive after 10 years compared with 9% of 257 patients who had incomplete resection of metastases and 2% of 505 patients who did not have any resection of metastases, said researchers from the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. Those differences achieved statistical significance
(P < .001).

"These results emphasize the importance of considering complete surgical resection of all resectable metastatic lesions in patients with renal cell carcinoma to achieve durable survival," said Angela Alt, MD, a resident in the department of urology at the Mayo Clinic.

In their retrospective study, Dr. Alt and colleagues identified 887 patients treated with radical nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma between 1976 and 2006 who had multiple metastatic lesions either prior to or following nephrectomy. Most of the patients were treated at the Mayo clinic for their primary operation (abstract 317).

On reviewing data on patients with lung metastases, they found that the 10-year survival rate among those who had all the lung lesions resected was about 50%, compared with about 10% of those patients who had incomplete surgical resection (P < .001).

"We believe the better survival we see in the patients who undergo complete resection has to do with the decrease of tumor burden," Dr. Alt said, adding that "surgical resection of all metastases should be considered if technically feasible prior to patient randomization in systemic therapy trials.

"It will be important to determine which features are important in selecting patients for complete surgical resection," she said.


Commenting on the study was E. Jason Abel, MD, a fellow in urologic oncology at Houston's M.D. Anderson Cancer Center.

"It is difficult to know whether the association of improved survival with complete resection of metastatic disease is a cause and effect relationship based on a retrospective study," Dr. Abel said.

"It is likely that patients chosen for surgery are healthier and have a smaller volume of disease in a more favorable location compared to the average patient with metastatic renal cell carcinoma," he suggested.

Dr. Abel added that it would be interesting to see how the role of surgery for metastatic disease evolved with the improvement of systemic therapy.

The role of surgery may expand in patients with minimal metastatic disease who have had significant response in their metastatic lesions, he said.

Related Videos
Data demonstrate the feasibility of automated glomerular filtration rate prediction to decide between partial nephrectomy and radical nephrectomy in kidney cancer, according to an expert from the Cleveland Clinic.
Experts on RCC
Experts on RCC
Early phase trials investigating cellular therapies, bispecific antibodies, and antibody-drug conjugates for refractory kidney cancer may uncover strategies to overcome resistance mechanisms.
Increasing cancer antigen presentation as well as working with tumor cells in and delivering novel cells to the microenvironment may help in overcoming mechanisms of immune checkpoint inhibitor resistance in refractory renal cell carcinoma.
Lenvatinib plus pembrolizumab appears to be the best option for patients with refractory metastatic renal cell carcinoma who are progressing on immunotherapy combinations or are lenvatinib naïve.
Ipilimumab monotherapy does not appear effective in driving complete responses in refractory renal cell carcinoma despite yielding some progression-free survival intervals, according to an expert from the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center.
An expert from the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center discusses several phase 3 clinical trials supporting the use of various single-agent and combination immunotherapy regimens for advanced kidney cancer.
Experts on RCC
Experts on RCC
Related Content