Global BulletinAll NewsFDA Approval AlertWomen in Oncology
Expert InterviewsAround the PracticeBetween the LinesFace OffFrom All AnglesMeeting of the MindsOncViewPodcastsTraining AcademyTreatment Algorithms with the Oncology BrothersVideos
Conferences
All JournalsEditorial BoardFor AuthorsYear in Review
Frontline ForumSatellite Sessions
CME/CE
Awareness MonthInteractive ToolsNurse Practitioners/Physician's AssistantsPartnersSponsoredSponsored Media
Career CenterSubscribe
Adverse Effects
Brain Cancer
Breast CancerBreast CancerBreast Cancer
Gastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal Cancer
Genitourinary CancersGenitourinary CancersGenitourinary CancersGenitourinary Cancers
Gynecologic CancersGynecologic CancersGynecologic CancersGynecologic Cancers
Head & Neck Cancer
Hematologic OncologyHematologic OncologyHematologic OncologyHematologic Oncology
InfectionInfection
Leukemia
Lung CancerLung CancerLung Cancer
Lymphoma
Neuroendocrine Tumors
Oncology
Pediatric Cancers
Radiation Oncology
Sarcoma
Screening
Skin Cancer & Melanoma
Surgery
Thyroid Cancer
Spotlight -
  • Radiation Oncology
  • Surgery
Adverse Effects
Brain Cancer
Breast CancerBreast CancerBreast Cancer
Gastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal CancerGastrointestinal Cancer
Genitourinary CancersGenitourinary CancersGenitourinary CancersGenitourinary Cancers
Gynecologic CancersGynecologic CancersGynecologic CancersGynecologic Cancers
Head & Neck Cancer
Hematologic OncologyHematologic OncologyHematologic OncologyHematologic Oncology
InfectionInfection
Leukemia
Lung CancerLung CancerLung Cancer
Lymphoma
Neuroendocrine Tumors
Oncology
Pediatric Cancers
Radiation Oncology
Sarcoma
Screening
Skin Cancer & Melanoma
Surgery
Thyroid Cancer
    • Conferences
    • CME/CE
    • Career Center
    • Subscribe

Your AI-Trained Oncology Knowledge Connection!

scout
Advertisement

With Genetic Tests, Informed Consent Enters Psychosocial Realm

August 1, 1997
Publication
Article
Oncology NEWS InternationalOncology NEWS International Vol 6 No 8
Volume 6
Issue 8

NEW ORLEANS--Informed consent has historically focused on physical risks, but genetic testing will move informed consent into psychosocial areas, Karen Rothenberg, JD, MPA, Marjorie Cook Professor of Law, University of Maryland School of Law, said at the 21st annual meeting of the American Society of Preventive Oncology (ASPO).

NEW ORLEANS--Informed consent has historically focused on physical risks,but genetic testing will move informed consent into psychosocial areas,Karen Rothenberg, JD, MPA, Marjorie Cook Professor of Law, University ofMaryland School of Law, said at the 21st annual meeting of the AmericanSociety of Preventive Oncology (ASPO).

With genetic testing, the informed consent process will need to addresssuch psychosocial risks as changes in self- image, altered family relationships,and possible stigmatization,

Patients must be told the potential benefits of genetic testing butalso the uncertainties, she said. For example, for many genetic tests forcancer, the true predictive value is unknown, the risk for misinterpretationis great, the effectiveness of prevention and intervention has not beensatisfactorily validated in trials, and the impact of testing on changesin health behavior is unknown.

Physicians must inform their patients that the legal protection of testresults is not uniform at this point, said Prof. Rothenberg, who is alsodirector of the Law and Health Care Program at the University of Maryland.

She said that about a dozen states prohibit health insurers from requestingthe results of genetic testing, from making coverage conditional on genetictesting, or from considering genetic testing in setting rates. Another20 states have laws pending.

"The catch is that except for a few states, most laws only protectthe genetic test result, not genetic information, such as might be obtainedfrom the family history in the medical record," she stressed.

In addition, states cannot regulate self-funded insurance plans, whichconstitute about half of all employee-provided insurance, Prof. Rothenbergsaid. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996,also called the Kassenbaum/Kennedy law, provides some protection. However,it cannot prohibit insurers from requesting disclosure of genetic information,increasing rates for patients with certain conditions or findings, or excludingfrom coverage all patients with certain conditions.

Few actual protections exist in the workplace, either, since again mostrestrictions apply to genetic test results, not genetic information. Employersare generally not prohibited from requesting medical releases, and theycan legally attempt to obtain access to information, she said.

Issues of Family Privacy

The area of family privacy is especially controversial now. Issues includethe right of the patient and other family members to know or not know testresults, the individual's responsibility to share information with familymembers, reproductive decision making, and genetic testing of children.

"In the informed consent process, there needs to be discussionabout family sharing of information," Professor Rothenberg said. "Andpeople need to recognize that having genetic information can change theirresponsibilities, obligations, even rights."

Articles in this issue

Two-Step Approach Urged to Avoid High Tech, Wild Death
Health Insurance Premiums Tax Proposed
ODAC Votes Yes on Taxol for Kaposi's Sarcoma
Five Principles Help Resolve Ethical Dilemmas in Care
Ovarian Cancer Survivors Form National Coalition
Photodynamic Therapy Used in Nonmelanoma Skin Cancer

Newsletter

Stay up to date on recent advances in the multidisciplinary approach to cancer.

Subscribe Now!
Recent Videos
The requirement for morphological dysplasia may become less important in the presence of molecular drivers of myelodysplastic syndrome.
Related Content

ABBV-706 Demonstrates Tumor Shrinkage, Tolerability in Pretreated R/R SCLC

ABBV-706 Demonstrates Tumor Shrinkage, Tolerability in Pretreated R/R SCLC

Ashling Wahner
September 10th 2025
Article

Upfront risk stratification for additional cardiovascular testing may help mitigate cardiovascular toxicities in breast cancer treatment.

Cardiovascular Considerations in Breast Cancer Treatment and Survivorship

Joseph S. Wallins, MD, MPH
September 10th 2025
Podcast

Crizotinib Falls Short on DFS and OS Improvements in ALK+ NSCLC

Crizotinib Falls Short on DFS and OS Improvements in ALK+ NSCLC

Jax DiEugenio
September 10th 2025
Article

Man Up? The Truth About Men's Health After Cancer

Man Up? The Truth About Men's Health After Cancer

Daniel C. McFarland, DO;Christian J. Nelson, PhD
September 10th 2025
Podcast

ProSense® is a minimally invasive treatment option that destroys tumors by freezing them, utilizing liquid nitrogen to create large lethal zones for maximum efficacy in tumor destruction.

ProSense® Cryoablation Satisfies Patients With Breast Cancer vs Alternatives

Tim Cortese
September 10th 2025
Article

Frontline Aumolertinib/Chemo Yields PFS Superiority in EGFR+ NSCLC

Frontline Aumolertinib/Chemo Yields PFS Superiority in EGFR+ NSCLC

Jax DiEugenio
September 10th 2025
Article
Related Content

ABBV-706 Demonstrates Tumor Shrinkage, Tolerability in Pretreated R/R SCLC

ABBV-706 Demonstrates Tumor Shrinkage, Tolerability in Pretreated R/R SCLC

Ashling Wahner
September 10th 2025
Article

Upfront risk stratification for additional cardiovascular testing may help mitigate cardiovascular toxicities in breast cancer treatment.

Cardiovascular Considerations in Breast Cancer Treatment and Survivorship

Joseph S. Wallins, MD, MPH
September 10th 2025
Podcast

Crizotinib Falls Short on DFS and OS Improvements in ALK+ NSCLC

Crizotinib Falls Short on DFS and OS Improvements in ALK+ NSCLC

Jax DiEugenio
September 10th 2025
Article

Man Up? The Truth About Men's Health After Cancer

Man Up? The Truth About Men's Health After Cancer

Daniel C. McFarland, DO;Christian J. Nelson, PhD
September 10th 2025
Podcast

ProSense® is a minimally invasive treatment option that destroys tumors by freezing them, utilizing liquid nitrogen to create large lethal zones for maximum efficacy in tumor destruction.

ProSense® Cryoablation Satisfies Patients With Breast Cancer vs Alternatives

Tim Cortese
September 10th 2025
Article

Frontline Aumolertinib/Chemo Yields PFS Superiority in EGFR+ NSCLC

Frontline Aumolertinib/Chemo Yields PFS Superiority in EGFR+ NSCLC

Jax DiEugenio
September 10th 2025
Article
Advertisement
About
Advertise
CureToday.com
OncLive.com
OncNursingNews.com
TargetedOnc.com
Editorial
Contact
Terms and Conditions
Privacy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

259 Prospect Plains Rd, Bldg H,
Monroe, NJ 08831

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.